Transcendence is directed by Wally Pfister. This
is his directorial debut. He is a cinematographer, mostly known for his work on
the past six Christopher Nolan movies. And Christopher Nolan is a producer of
this movie. This film stars Johnny Depp, Rebecca Hall, Morgan Freeman, Cillian
Murphy, Paul Bettany, and Kate Mara. It is about three scientists (Bettany, Hall,
and Depp). Two of the scientists (Depp and Hall) are husband and wife. The scientists
are working on inventing artificial intelligence, but Johnny Depp’s character
gets shot by a bullet laced with radiation. The group of people who did this is
highly against inventing A.I. One of them is played by Kate Mara. Anyway, Depp’s
character does not have much time left, so Hall’s character decides to upload
his conscience into the computer to save him. Though, they do not know if he is
a computer or really Depp’s character. After that… some things happen.
This movie
had so many things going for it. It had a very interesting premise that could make
a great movie, a fantastic cast, and it is produced by Christopher Nolan.
Though, it does have a first-time-writer and -director, which could go wrong.
It does.
This is a
big let-down. It is a very dull movie. But it also has other flaws, like with
the overall direction. We see to have no influence over the actors. They have nothing
to bounce off of. It seemed like he just told them to do what the script says
their characters do. It also seems like Pfister had no control over the scene
in the movie. There seems to be no tone. It was just the scene written in the
script. And the pacing was not handled at all. I would say it was handled
horribly, but Wally Pfister did not but anything into the movie that the script
did not have. Because of all of these things, the movie came off very bland and
dull. The movie did look good. That seemed to be the only thing Pfister cared
about as a director.
The script
was also very bad, too. It seemed that the writer was only interested in a few
scenes in this movie. He did not think about the buildup to that scene. Because
of that, there were a lot of scenes, all very, very short. It did seem like it
was fast-moving that way, but it was still dull and nothing was happening that
way. The dialogue here is also written incredibly lazily. For example, at one
point a character asks a question then makes a statement. Then, another character
answers the question a second later. That does not reflect human conversation.
The person would have asked the question, and then while they were making the
statement the other would be answering the question. But the writer did not want
to add in the interruption.
The script
also has other problems. There is no character depth. Sometimes a character
will talk about something that happened in the past, but it will not give them depth.
Because of that, every character was two-dimensional and I did not care about
any of them. Also, nothing really happened after the half-way mark of the movie.
After the middle, it just got really boring. There were no stakes.
While the
script does have many bad things, there were hints of greatness here. For maybe
one scene, I could see just small pieces of greatness. And there were some
really great ideas in here.
The actors
here are trying, but there is nothing here. Johnny Depp and Rebecca Hall are
trying to be good, but they do not come off as good. Cillian Murphy and Morgan
Freeman really do not have much to do here, and they are at about the same
level as Hall and Depp, except maybe a bit higher. Paul Bettany is actually
good in this movie and Kate Mara is the same as the others: trying but cannot
really do anything. She actually comes off the worst of all of them. Her
performance seems bad, but it is not her fault, which applies to all of the
other actors that did not come off as good.
This is just
a bland and dull movie throughout the entire running time. After the middle
most of it was boring, and that was when I would start looking at the time
every five minutes, wondering when it would end. It would do this think where
it would get really interesting for a twenty-five second scene, then cut to another
where it would be boring for another five minutes. That pattern repeated for most
of the second half of the movie.
Yes, there
were some themes in this movie, and some ideas it introduced, but because the
narrative made no sense, the themes the film brings do not make sense. And the
themes are told in such a straightforward manner that you do not even have to
think to get them. They are told directly to the audience, so they are barely
even a positive to the movie. Though, some of the ideas it introduces work
really well. It is just that the thought-provoking elements do not work as
well.
Transcendence is a dull, poorly written,
poorly directed film. Although it does have some glimpses of greatness and some
great ideas, they do not save the movie. Pfister did not take control of the
scenes. He only worried about the visuals.